Skip to content
Get a Free Share

GIA vs ISA: the difference between the two account types

By Chris

A Stocks and Shares ISA and a General Investment Account (GIA) can hold the same investments. The difference is tax: inside an ISA you pay no UK tax on income or gains, but you can only pay in £20,000 a tax year. A GIA has no limit and no tax shelter. This guide is general information, not advice on which to use.

The short answer

An ISA is a tax wrapper. A GIA is a plain investment account with no wrapper. You can hold shares, funds and ETFs in either, and the investments behave the same way: their prices move, and they can fall as well as rise. What changes is how the UK taxes what happens inside the account.

In a Stocks and Shares ISA you pay no UK tax on dividends or gains, and you don’t declare them on a tax return. In exchange, you can only pay in up to £20,000 in the 2026 to 2027 tax year, across all your ISAs. In a GIA you can pay in as much as you like, but dividends and gains above your yearly allowances can be taxed. Tax treatment depends on your circumstances, and gov.uk and HMRC are the places to check the detail.

GIA and ISA side by side

 Stocks and Shares ISAGeneral Investment Account
How much you can pay in£20,000 a tax year across all your ISAsNo limit
Tax on dividendsNoneAbove the £500 dividend allowance, at your dividend rate
Tax on gains when you sellNoneAbove the £3,000 annual exempt amount, at 18% or 24%
On your tax returnNot declaredMay need reporting if over your allowances
Who can open oneUK residents aged 18 or over (Junior ISAs for under-18s)Set by each provider
Free shares from appsNot paid in hereWhere they land

Rates and allowances from gov.uk for the 2026 to 2027 tax year. They can change at each Budget.

Tax on gains and dividends

Capital gains

A gain is the difference between what you paid for an investment and what you sold it for. Gov.uk says shares that are not in an ISA are among the investments you may pay Capital Gains Tax on, and that you don’t pay it when you dispose of shares you’ve put into an ISA.

Outside an ISA, everyone has an annual exempt amount of £3,000. It covers your total gains across the tax year, from all your non-ISA investments and other assets, not each account separately. Gains above it are taxed at 18% if they fall within your basic-rate band, and 24% above it.

Dividends

Gov.uk says you don’t pay tax on dividends from shares in an ISA. In a GIA, dividend income within your Personal Allowance is untaxed, and you also get a dividend allowance of £500 a year. Above that, dividends are taxed at 10.75% in the basic-rate band, 35.75% in the higher-rate band and 39.35% in the additional-rate band. These rates apply from 6 April 2026.

For many people with a small GIA, these allowances mean there is no tax to pay in a given year. The larger a GIA’s dividends or gains, the more likely they are to go over them.

How the rates apply: an illustration

These are round, made-up figures, chosen only to show how the allowances and rates work. They are not a forecast of dividends or gains on any investment, and they ignore other income, which can change the answer.

Dividends received in a GIA in a year£1,500
Covered by the dividend allowance£500
Taxable dividends£1,000
Tax at the basic rate (10.75%)£107.50
Tax at the higher rate (35.75%)£357.50

Take a gain instead. If you sold investments in a GIA and made a gain of £5,000 in one tax year, the first £3,000 would be covered by the annual exempt amount, leaving £2,000. At 18% that is £360; at 24% it is £480. Some of a gain can fall in each band, depending on your income.

The same dividends or the same gain inside a Stocks and Shares ISA would carry no UK tax.

US shares in either account

The ISA wrapper is a UK tax rule, so it doesn’t switch off US tax. US tax on dividends from US shares is generally withheld before the money reaches you, in either account. With a valid W-8BEN form, the UK/US tax treaty caps that withholding on portfolio dividends at 15%, rather than the default 30%. Our guide to the W-8BEN form explains how that works and how long the form lasts.

The ISA allowance

Gov.uk says you can save up to £20,000 in ISAs in the 2026 to 2027 tax year, in one account or split across several. The tax year runs from 6 April to 5 April, and each tax year has its own allowance.

Your ISAs don’t close when the tax year ends: investments already inside stay sheltered for as long as you keep them there. That is why some people try to use the allowance each year when they can. A GIA has no allowance to use up, which is why people who invest more than the ISA limit often hold both.

At Budget 2026 on 28 October 2026, the overall allowance was left unchanged, and the cash ISA limit stays at £20,000 from April 2027 (the planned cut was reversed at Budget 2026). It also said the government will explore a new incentive for first-time Stocks and Shares ISA investors; no details have been published.

Transfers and moving money

Moving an ISA to another provider

Gov.uk says you can transfer all or part of an ISA from one provider to another at any time. To keep the tax shelter, you ask the new provider to arrange it with an ISA transfer form. If you withdraw the money yourself instead, you can’t reinvest that part of your allowance again. Gov.uk says transfers other than cash ISA to cash ISA should take no longer than 30 calendar days.

Providers can charge for transfers. Freetrade, for example, charges £17 per US holding to transfer US holdings out, and says transfers out are free for UK shares and cash. Our Freetrade ISA guide covers its transfers in and out.

Moving holdings from a GIA into an ISA

You can’t move existing GIA shares straight into an ISA. Gov.uk says you cannot transfer any non-ISA shares you already own into an ISA, unless they come from an employee share scheme. To invest through an ISA, you pay cash in, and that cash counts towards the year’s allowance however you came by it. Selling investments in a GIA to raise that cash is a disposal for Capital Gains Tax, so the tax rules above apply to the sale.

Why free shares land in a GIA

Free shares from investing apps go into a GIA, not an ISA. Freetrade’s free-share FAQ says the share will “drop into your GIA” and that it can’t put free shares into an ISA or SIPP for tax reasons.

Freetrade doesn’t explain further, but the gov.uk rules above are relevant: shares you already own can’t be transferred into an ISA, and what goes in is money you pay in within the allowance. Other apps do the same. Lightyear’s sign-up reward lands in a GIA. IG’s current offer pays its reward into a GIA.

So a free share follows GIA tax rules. Any dividends it pays count towards your dividend allowance, and a gain when you sell counts towards your annual exempt amount. HMRC has no guidance written specifically about free shares from investing apps, so how the share itself is treated when you receive it is less clear; our guide to free share tax sets out what HMRC’s manuals do say. Selling and withdrawing come with their own rules, covered in selling your free share.

Freetrade’s free share is worth £10 to £100 when it is awarded. The share is picked at random. About 80% are worth £10 to £25, and its value can fall after you get it. You can read how the Freetrade free share works for the full conditions.

How people tend to use each

This is a description of common patterns, not a recommendation. Which account suits you depends on your own circumstances.

  • ISA first, GIA for the rest. Many people use their ISA allowance each year and use a GIA only for money above it, because the ISA keeps future dividends and gains out of UK tax.
  • A GIA for things an ISA can’t hold. Free shares from apps are the obvious example. Gov.uk lists what a Stocks and Shares ISA can include, and some products sit outside it.
  • A GIA when the allowance is used. Once you have paid in the year’s £20,000, a GIA is where further investing goes until the next tax year.
  • Both at one provider. Many platforms offer both. Freetrade, for example, says the Stocks and Shares ISA, Junior ISA, SIPP and GIA are on every plan, including Basic.

Protection is the same either way. FSCS cover depends on the firm, not the account type, and applies up to £85,000 per person, per firm if an authorised firm fails and assets are missing; our guide to FSCS protection for investments explains it. Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and can change; gov.uk and HMRC have the current rules.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a GIA and an ISA?

Both can hold the same kinds of shares and funds. In a Stocks and Shares ISA you pay no UK tax on income or capital gains, but you can only pay in up to £20,000 a tax year across all your ISAs. A General Investment Account has no limit on what you pay in, but gains above the £3,000 allowance and dividends above the £500 allowance can be taxed.

Can I move shares from my GIA into my ISA?

Not directly. Gov.uk says you cannot transfer non-ISA shares you already own into an ISA, unless they come from an employee share scheme. Money you pay into an ISA counts towards that year’s allowance, wherever it comes from. Selling shares held in a GIA counts as a disposal for Capital Gains Tax, so tax treatment depends on your circumstances.

Why does my free share go into a GIA and not my ISA?

Freetrade’s free-share FAQ says the share drops into your GIA because it can’t put free shares into an ISA or SIPP for tax reasons. It lands in your General Investment Account (GIA), not an ISA or SIPP. Other apps' sign-up rewards work the same way. While it sits in the GIA, any gain when you sell and any dividends fall under the normal GIA tax rules.

Do I pay tax on dividends in a GIA?

Only on dividends above your allowance. Everyone gets a dividend allowance of £500 a year, and dividend income within your Personal Allowance is also untaxed. Above that, gov.uk lists rates of 10.75%, 35.75% and 39.35% depending on your Income Tax band. Dividends from shares in an ISA are not taxed. Tax treatment depends on your circumstances.

Do I need to put ISA income on a tax return?

No. Gov.uk says that if you complete a tax return, you do not need to declare ISA interest, income or capital gains. Dividends and gains in a GIA are different: if they go over your allowances, you may need to report them to HMRC. The rules depend on your circumstances, so check gov.uk or ask HMRC.

Is a GIA or an ISA better protected by the FSCS?

Neither. FSCS protection depends on the firm, not the account type. It covers eligible investments up to £85,000 per person, per firm, if an authorised firm fails and assets are missing. It never covers a fall in the value of your investments, in a GIA or an ISA.

Sources

  1. GOV.UK: Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs)
  2. GOV.UK: Capital Gains Tax allowances
  3. GOV.UK: Capital Gains Tax rates
  4. GOV.UK: Tax on dividends
  5. GOV.UK: Budget 2026 overview of tax legislation and rates (OOTLAR) (28 October 2026)
  6. HMRC: Tax-free savings newsletter 24 (October 2026)
  7. IRS: Withholding on US-source income paid to nonresident aliens
  8. HMRC Double Taxation Relief Manual DT19852: UK/USA treaty
  9. HMRC Business Income Manual BIM100210: cash-backs
  10. Freetrade: Free share (offer page and FAQ)
  11. Freetrade: ISA transfers
  12. FSCS: Investments
  13. GOV.UK: Individual Savings Accounts, how ISAs work
  14. GOV.UK: Individual Savings Accounts, transferring your ISA
  15. GOV.UK: Tax when you sell shares

Figures last checked 19 November 2026. If something has changed, tell us and we will correct it.

Get the link on your phone

Freetrade signs you up in its mobile app, so the link works best on your phone. Point your phone’s camera at the code to open it there.

You and the friend who refers you each get one free share worth £10 to £100, picked at random. Most are worth £10 to £25. To qualify you must never have had a Freetrade account, be a UK tax resident (not a US national), complete a W-8BEN and add at least £50 net within 30 calendar days of using the link.

Or carry on from this computer

Open Freetrade's sign-up

Opens Freetrade's sign-up · Referral link

Referral link: if you join and qualify, we both get a free share. How we make money

Capital at risk. The value of investments can go down as well as up, and you may get back less than you put in. This site gives general information, not financial advice, and is not authorised by the FCA. Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and may change.