Freetrade vs Lightyear: two low-cost apps compared
By Chris
Freetrade and Lightyear both charge no dealing commission. Lightyear’s FX fee on US shares is lower and it has no paid plans; Freetrade has a SIPP and a Junior ISA, which Lightyear does not list. Here are the costs, accounts and free-share offers side by side, with no winner declared.
The short answer
Lightyear is cheaper for buying US shares, because its FX fee is 0.1% and it charges no account fee. Freetrade’s FX fee is 0.99% on its free Basic plan, falling to 0.59% and 0.39% on plans that cost a monthly fee. For UK shares and ETFs bought in pounds, the two cost about the same: no account fee on the entry option and no commission.
The bigger differences are the accounts. Freetrade offers a SIPP (a self-invested personal pension) and a Junior ISA, and the Stocks and Shares ISA, Junior ISA, SIPP and GIA are on every plan, including Basic. Lightyear lists Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA, GIA and Business accounts (no SIPP listed). If a pension in the same app matters to you, that settles a lot. If you only want a Stocks and Shares ISA or a GIA, both do the job and the FX fee does most of the talking.
Both run a free-share offer, and they work differently. This page compares published figures. The Lightyear side comes from Lightyear’s own pages, not from using its app, and every figure has a source listed at the end.
Freetrade and Lightyear side by side
The table uses each provider’s own pricing page, checked on 19 November 2026. Fees change, so check before you decide.
| Feature | FreetradeBasic, Standard or Plus | LightyearFigures from Lightyear’s own pages |
|---|---|---|
| Platform or account fee | Basic £0. Standard £4.99 a month billed annually (£5.99 a month if billed monthly). Plus £9.99 a month billed annually (£11.99 a month if billed monthly) | no account fee |
| UK share dealing | £0 dealing commission on every plan | free per order |
| US share dealing | £0 dealing commission on every plan, plus the FX fee | free per order, plus the FX fee |
| FX fee | 0.99% on Basic, 0.59% on Standard, 0.39% on Plus | 0.1% |
| Accounts | Stocks and Shares ISA, Junior ISA, SIPP and GIA, on every plan including Basic | Stocks and Shares ISA, Cash ISA, GIA and Business accounts (no SIPP listed) |
| Fractional shares | US fractional shares, on every plan | yes |
| Interest on cashVariable rates | Basic: 1% AER on up to £1,000. Standard: 2.5% AER on up to £2,000. Plus: 3.5% AER on up to £3,000 | interest on cash in Vaults and a Cash ISA (the page shows more than one rate; check it) |
| Joining offer | One free share worth £10 to £100 through a customer’s referral link; about 80% are worth £10 to £25. Add £50 net within 30 calendar days | a fractional share or ETF worth £10 to £100 (about 80% worth £10 to £20). Selected promo codes or an invite only; deposit £100 |
| FCA firm | Freetrade Limited, FRN 783189 | Lightyear UK Ltd, FRN 987226 |
Freetrade vs Lightyear: fees, accounts and offers. Each provider’s own page is listed in Sources below. Fees change; check before you decide.
Opens Freetrade's sign-up · Referral link
Referral link: if you join and qualify, we both get a free share. How we make money
Capital at risk. The value of investments can go down as well as up, and you may get back less than you put in. This site gives general information, not financial advice, and is not authorised by the FCA. Tax treatment depends on your circumstances and may change.
Fees and the FX charge
Neither app charges a commission when you buy or sell shares. The costs that matter are the platform fee, if you pay one, and the foreign exchange fee when you buy something priced in another currency, such as a US share.
How Freetrade charges
Freetrade has three plans. Basic costs £0 and carries the highest FX fee, 0.99%. Standard costs £4.99 a month billed annually (£59.88 a year) or £5.99 a month billed monthly, with an FX fee of 0.59%. Plus costs £9.99 a month billed annually (£119.88 a year) or £11.99 a month billed monthly, with an FX fee of 0.39%. The paid plans also pay more interest on uninvested cash and add extras such as enhanced stock fundamentals.
The ISA and SIPP are not paid add-ons: they are on Basic too. Our full breakdown of Freetrade’s fees and plans covers the transfer-out charges and the SIPP’s withdrawal fee as well.
How Lightyear charges
Lightyear’s pricing page lists no account fee, UK and US share orders as free per order, and an FX fee of 0.1%. There is no subscription tier to choose between, so the FX fee is the same for everyone.
That makes the comparison simple for anyone who buys US shares: per pound converted, Lightyear’s fee is a fraction of Freetrade’s on any plan. Freetrade’s paid plans narrow the gap on FX but add a fixed yearly cost.
Worked cost examples
These examples use illustrative amounts to show how the fees add up over a year. They show costs only, not what any investment might be worth, and they assume you buy US shares and convert pounds to dollars once. Selling and converting back would usually mean a second FX charge on each platform.
| US shares bought in a year | Freetrade Basic | Freetrade Standard | Freetrade Plus | Lightyear |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| £2,000 | £19.80 | £71.68 | £127.68 | £2 |
| £10,000 | £99 | £118.88 | £158.88 | £10 |
Here is the working for £2,000. On Freetrade Basic, 0.99% of £2,000 is £19.80, with no plan fee. On Standard, the FX fee is £11.80, plus £59.88 a year for the plan billed annually, so £71.68 in total. On Plus it is £7.80 plus £119.88 a year, so £127.68. On Lightyear, 0.1% of £2,000 is £2.
At £10,000 the pattern holds: £99 on Freetrade Basic, £118.88 on Standard, £158.88 on Plus and £10 on Lightyear. On fees alone, Freetrade Standard only costs less than Basic once you convert about £14,970 a year, and none of Freetrade’s plans gets close to Lightyear on this measure. Billing Standard monthly instead of annually raises the plan cost to £71.88 a year.
If you hold only UK shares and ETFs bought in pounds, there is no FX fee to pay, so Freetrade Basic and Lightyear both come to £0 in platform and dealing charges in this simple view. To try your own figures across Freetrade’s three plans, use the plan cost calculator.
Fees are only part of the picture. A cheaper platform does not make any investment less risky, and prices can fall as well as rise whichever app you use.
Accounts: ISA, SIPP and the rest
Stocks and Shares ISA. Both offer one. Gains and income inside an ISA are free of UK tax, and you can pay in up to £20,000 across all your ISAs in the 2026 to 2027 tax year. On Freetrade the ISA is on every plan, including Basic. Our guide to the Freetrade ISA covers transfers and how the allowance works there.
SIPP. Freetrade has one on every plan. Its SIPP charges £240 per UFPLS withdrawal (an uncrystallised funds pension lump sum, one way of taking money out) and has no SIPP transfer-out or exit fee. Lightyear’s pricing page lists no SIPP. If you want your pension and your ISA in one app, Freetrade covers that and Lightyear, on its published list, does not.
Junior ISA. Freetrade lists one; it is not among the accounts Lightyear’s pricing page lists.
Cash ISA and business accounts. These run the other way. Lightyear lists a Cash ISA and Business accounts. Freetrade’s plan page lists neither: its accounts are the Stocks and Shares ISA, Junior ISA, SIPP and GIA.
GIA. Both have a General Investment Account, which has no annual limit and no tax wrapper. Both free-share offers pay into a GIA, not an ISA. Our guide to GIAs and ISAs explains the tax difference between them.
Fractional shares, orders and cash
Fractional shares. Both offer them. Freetrade lists US fractional shares on every plan, and Lightyear pays its own sign-up reward as a fractional share or ETF. Fractional shares let you put a set amount of money into a share whose full price is more than you want to spend.
Order types and features. Freetrade lists recurring, limit and stop-loss orders, extended hours, US fractional shares, T-bills, mutual funds, gilts and ready-made portfolios on every plan, across 9,000+ instruments. Lightyear publishes its own feature list on its site; we have not set the two lists against each other order type by order type, so check Lightyear’s pages if a particular order type matters to you.
Interest on cash. Freetrade pays interest on uninvested cash at a rate and cap that depend on the plan: 1% AER on up to £1,000 on Basic, 2.5% AER on up to £2,000 on Standard and 3.5% AER on up to £3,000 on Plus. Lightyear offers interest on cash in Vaults and a Cash ISA (the page shows more than one rate; check it). Rates are variable on both, and interest on spare cash is a feature, not a reason to pick an investing app.
The two free-share offers
Both apps offer new customers a free share, and the two offers look alike on the surface: a random share, most often near the bottom of the range, paid into a GIA and locked for a period. The differences are in who can get one and what you have to do.
Freetrade’s offer
Freetrade’s refer-a-friend offer is advertised as live on freetrade.io. If an existing customer refers you and you qualify, you each get one share worth £10 to £100, a random pick from a pool of US and UK companies, ETFs and trusts. The share is picked at random. About 80% are worth £10 to £25, and its value can fall after you get it.
- 80% £10 to £25
- 15% £25.01 to £50
- 3% £50.01 to £75
- 2% £75.01 to £100
To qualify you must be new to Freetrade, a UK tax resident (US nationals are excluded), complete a W-8BEN form and add £50 net within 30 calendar days. Freetrade’s FAQ says shares are revealed usually within 7 to 10 days of qualifying; its terms say it aims to award shares within 28 business days. Cash from selling it can only be withdrawn after 180 calendar days. Our page on how the Freetrade free share works covers each rule, and the free share odds tool shows what a share is likely to be worth.
Lightyear’s offer
Lightyear offers a fractional share or ETF worth £10 to £100 (about 80% worth £10 to £20). Its conditions, from its own terms:
- New users with selected promo codes, or an invite from a customer Lightyear has chosen.
- Deposit £100 within 15 days of onboarding (30 days for referrals).
- Lands in a GIA; locked for 6 months, and removed if you withdraw the first deposit within 6 months.
The main practical difference is access. Lightyear’s reward comes through selected promo codes or an invite from a customer Lightyear has picked, so not everyone has a route in at any given time. Freetrade’s comes through any customer’s referral link. Lightyear’s minimum deposit is also higher, £100 against £50, and that money is yours and at risk once invested. Lightyear explains its offer on its sign-up reward page.
Either provider can change or end its offer at any time. Our roundup of free share offers in the UK tracks what is live, with checked dates.
Regulation and protection
Both are authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority: Freetrade Limited (FRN 783189) and Lightyear UK Ltd (FRN 987226). Freetrade holds customer investments through Freetrade Nominees Limited under the FCA's client assets rules (CASS), and since 2025 it has been owned by IG Group Holdings plc, a FTSE 100 company.
FSCS investment protection is set per person, per firm, up to £85,000. It is there for when a firm fails and assets are missing, not for when prices fall. Our explainer on FSCS protection for investments covers how that works, and our guide to whether Freetrade is safe looks at Freetrade’s set-up in detail. For Lightyear’s arrangements, read its own terms.
Where Lightyear is cheaper
Being straight about it, Lightyear comes out ahead on several points:
Where Lightyear is ahead
- A lower FX fee: 0.1% against 0.99% on Freetrade Basic
- No paid tiers, so there is no plan to weigh up
- A Cash ISA and Business accounts, which Freetrade does not list
Where Freetrade is ahead
- A SIPP and a Junior ISA, on every plan including Basic
- A free-share offer open through any customer’s referral link, not only selected promo codes or invites
- A smaller deposit for the free share: £50 net against £100
If most of what you buy is priced in dollars, the FX fee is likely to be the largest cost you pay on either app, and Lightyear’s is lower.
Who each tends to suit
There is no single winner here. Which fits depends on what you hold and which accounts you need.
Freetrade tends to suit people who want a SIPP, a Stocks and Shares ISA and a GIA in one app, parents who want a Junior ISA alongside their own accounts, and people who mostly buy UK shares and ETFs in pounds, where the free Basic plan has no FX cost to worry about. It also suits anyone who wants a free share through a friend’s referral link rather than waiting for a promo code.
Lightyear tends to suit people who buy a lot of US shares and want the lowest FX fee of the two, people who want a Cash ISA or a business account from the same provider, and people who would rather not choose between paid plans.
Some people use both: one app for a pension or ISA, another for dollar-priced shares in a GIA. Before you join either, check that you qualify for any offer you want; our four-question eligibility check covers Freetrade’s. This page is general information, not advice, and the value of investments can fall as well as rise.
Frequently asked questions
Is Lightyear cheaper than Freetrade?
On US shares, usually yes. Lightyear’s FX fee is 0.1% with no account fee, while Freetrade’s is 0.99% on the free Basic plan and lower on paid plans that cost a monthly fee. On UK shares and ETFs the platform costs are close: both charge no account fee on their entry option and no dealing commission. Stamp duty on UK share purchases applies on any platform.
Does Lightyear have a SIPP?
Lightyear’s pricing page lists a Stocks and Shares ISA, a Cash ISA, a GIA and Business accounts, and no SIPP. Freetrade lists a SIPP alongside its ISA, Junior ISA and GIA, and all of them are available on every plan, including Basic. If a self-invested pension in the same app matters to you, that is a real difference. Check Lightyear’s site in case this changes.
Does Lightyear have a free share offer?
Yes, with limits. Lightyear offers a fractional share or ETF worth £10 to £100 (about 80% worth £10 to £20), through selected promo codes or an invite from a customer Lightyear has chosen. You deposit £100 within a set window, and the reward lands in a GIA, locked for six months. Freetrade’s offer is £10 to £100 through any customer’s referral link, with £50 of net funding. Both values are random and can fall.
Can I get a free share from both Freetrade and Lightyear?
They are separate companies with separate offers, and each offer is for people new to that provider, so joining one does not by itself rule you out of the other. Each has its own conditions, deposit, deadline and lock-in period, and either can change or end its offer at any time. Read both sets of terms before you rely on either.
Is the FX fee charged when I sell a US share as well as when I buy?
A currency conversion happens whenever pounds become dollars or dollars become pounds, so selling a US share and moving the proceeds back to sterling usually means a second conversion. The worked examples on this page show buying only, to keep the comparison simple. Check each provider’s own pricing page for exactly when its fee applies.
Is my free share from either app protected by the FSCS?
Both firms are authorised by the FCA, and FSCS investment protection is set per person, per firm, up to £85,000. It applies if a firm fails and assets are missing, not if the share’s price falls. A free share is an investment like any other once it is in your account, so its value can go down as well as up.
Sources
- Freetrade: Compare plans
- Freetrade Free Share Terms & Conditions v7 (Version 7, valid from 6 November 2024)
- Freetrade: Free share (offer page and FAQ)
- Freetrade: Terms and conditions (Version 4.9, April 2026)
- FSCS: Investments
- Freetrade: SIPP charges schedule (Version 7.2, April 2026)
- Lightyear: Pricing
- Lightyear: Sign-up reward
- Lightyear: Sign-up promotion terms
Figures last checked 19 November 2026. If something has changed, tell us and we will correct it.
Related reading
- Fees and plansEvery Freetrade fee from its own pricing page: plan prices, the FX fee on each plan, ISA and SIPP access, transfer-out costs and the charges people miss.
- Free shares UKEvery UK investing app currently offering a free share or joining bonus, checked against each provider's own page, with the conditions in plain English.
- vs Trading 212Freetrade against Trading 212: plan and FX costs, ISA and pension options, fractional shares, cash interest and who each tends to suit.
- ReviewAn independent Freetrade review: plans and the FX fee, the ISA and SIPP, fractional US shares, safety and ownership, support, and who should look elsewhere.